The Thanet Star

Councillor - this post is for you


Photo credit: iboy_daniel
At the time of writing 17 people have voted in the most recent poll where the question was Has Sandy Ezekiel brought his office or authority into disrepute 100% of those voted for the very last option And How! The man is a disgrace to Thanet! (Strongly Agree). However (as I mentioned recently) the election of a "leader" for the council descended into shouting and screaming when labour councillors had the gall to suggest Sandy Ezekiel not be elected. The roll of the Labour Party in this situation was, as the "opposition party", to suggest and argue well for an alternative. The fact that the conservatives at the centre of this disgrace did not want to listen suggests to me a party in crisis.

It suggests to me deals that once made could not be broken no matter how stupid they now seemed and how hard the results went against all good sense. It is common for people to see the council as having a hidden agenda (of their own) and these disgraceful actions only serve to reinforce that view. A view that many councillors actually do not seem to be aware of or, when those that do become aware, fully comprehend.

Cllr Mike Harrison recently commented

[...] please dont tar ALL Councillors with the same brush, there are quite a few on both sides of the political spectrum who are hard working, decent people just trying to do their best for the Community they represent and sticking to the principles in the Constitution.


This raises for me such a key and vital point that to do it justice I need a little more space than that offered by the comments. I did not want to take the basic thread too far off topic with a long comment on what would have been a side issue. The subject Cllr Mike Harrison raises is no side issue but possibly the most important issue in Thanet politics today.

Cllr Mike Harrison this post is for you.


Before I go any further I do not want anyone (least of all Cllr Mike Harrison) to think that I am getting at them personally (with one very obvious exception). I wish to explain something that I feel has been hidden from those that seek election locally. What has been hidden is, however, an unpleasant truth and I am not good a sugar coating such things.


Photo credit: freeparking
From the trenches one soldier, across nomansland, looks very much like another. If one is fine artist, another a humanitarian and a third "the greatest philosopher who ever lived" this does not matter when it comes time to pull the trigger. For must of the people in Thanet it is an us and them situation - The People of Thanet vs Thanet District Council. In any situation where the average citizen feels they must defend themselves from the ruling authority (local or not) all representatives will be seen as wearing the same uniform of "them on the other side trying to kill us". It is for this reason that all councillors are tarred with a single brush.

Individuality is a casualty of war!

Please don't get me wrong I understand with my head the differences between you but at a much more instinctual level (my gut reaction if you wish) I know only the uniform. They say that politics is as much about the hearts and minds of the people as the facts and the figures and it's true. Unfortunately for the council of Thanet the hearts of the people have truly been lost.

I understand on an impersonal and abstract (cold and logical) level that there are people (such as yourself (Cllr Mike Harrison) and a few others) that actually do reply to your fellow Thanetarians and do try to do right by the people. If I think hard about it I can even recognise that this is slowing the rate of decay around here.

However, my instinctual reaction (which I find is often closer to the "man on the street" opinion) makes all Councillors guilty by association. There is an ancient proverb "as the shepherd so too the sheep". What that means is that whatever the agenda of the "leader" might be, whatever path he might choose (or have chosen for him) that is the path that we all must follow. Kicking and screaming if need be.

It is my opinion that there are sufficient numbers of "bad" councillors that they have given all Councillors a bad name. To put it another way: the majority have brought the office of councillor in to disrepute in contravention of the constitution and against the will of the minority. More than that the sum total of the actions and choices of the Council corporately has trickled down to the people that do the actual work in such a way that bad work is heard to be described as "a council job".

Take for example Tony Flaigs blog post here wherein he writes that he discovered that work he had precviousely felt to be unacceptable and described as a pigs breakfast is then decribed as remarkable given that Thanet District Council were found to have been in charge. How did we get to a point whereby public opinion is that if TDC do only a crap jobt hen they have done better than expected?

When the name of one's local council has become a by-word for the worst possible outcome for a group project - not failure but incomprehensible disarray and pointless activity leading to no worthwhile end. When the name of the local authority is used to describe chaotic organisation (so that no one has any idea what is going on); where the result is a joke then there is a problem. Local bloggers talk of a lack of "joined up thinking" but I can tell you that is putting mildly what is said about all councillors (and the council with whom they are synonymous) on the council's own housing estates.

The system is broken and if you are not trying to fix the system, to improve and overcome it then you are seen as supporting the broken state of things. This is not because I or anyone else is being mean but it is because from a few paces back you actions must be bigger to be seen.

When I talk to a friend face to face a tiny gesture communicates a lot of information. On a stage with a large audience I must make my slightest action orders of magnitude bigger just to have a hope of communicating anything to the people past the first few rows. In Thanet only a third of people vote - that's the people in the first few rows the remainder don't see any significant advantage in voting at all.

Take, by way of an example this post by local track worker Tony Flaig - the very first comment and the person writes small wonder poeple will not vote.

Each party, each member has failed to act sufficiently to distinguish themselves in any way in the eyes of those "in the cheap seats" not only from each other but from the failure of past councils and the actions of the most prominent disgraces of the "main gang".

What looks bad from where we (the average voter) stands is that when the most dominant gang start screaming or shouting in session (as has been reported), or the Thanet District Council inexplicably make decisions in favour oft he minority rich and against the interests of the people or when the administrative section screw over a bunch of poor people in need of help not red tape (and they do, regularly - it looks from the outside like using the red tape and letter of the law to close a hole in the benefits budget); When all that happens and no one is seen to take a stand against it then, from the ground, each and every councillor is seen to give silent assent to these actions.

Let me give an example from the blog of local businessman Michael Child. Michael is writting about Thanet Earth and his chance to talk to local farmers. What none of them could understand, is why when the council gets involved in projects on agricultural land don’t they first consult the local farming community?

When ever the paid administration acts, whenever a benefits claim is processed, whenever the administration potentially breaks the law in summoning people to court, whenever it refuses benefit and backdates that so a person goes from debt free to CCJ in a single month; each time a member of staff is rude to someone; each time a document is lost; for each person where the same paperwork must be filed two or three times; for each department with key personnel with a reputation for making people cry (and they exist if you contact me personally I will tell you about it off the record on the condition that you act on what I tell you in a way that leads to results); for every missadministration; for every slight; for every roge staff member (like the one that stalked me for two years); for every failure of administration at every level it is you the elected council person that must carry the guilt in the eyes of the people.

Is it any wonder that I am willing to let things get far far worse before I admit that the only answer is to stand for election myself? The only problem being that I hurt my chances of getting elected by aligning myself with a party and limit the effect I can have by going independent (not to mention having to cover the costs myself).

Thanet is hurting and a large part of that directly caused by Thanet District Council as a corporate whole. People are desperate for someone to bring a solution. You can see the signs of it seeping out as the early warning signs (calls for parish councils, new political parties forming, the unusually high blog count, the very low vote count, other councils pointing and calling our council names; the list is endless.)


Photo credit: scottobear
When councillors fail to reply when people email or write (especially if they are poor, on benefits and living in an estate which seems to lead tot hem being ignored as a standard policy) it gives the impression that the council as a whole does not give a dam - this view is held up by the actions of many councillors and the inexplicable choices that are made without so much as a decent explanation why. If we count only the councillors for Dane Valley that were representing before the elections and those after we have 6 councillors and I have, to date, written so many letters I could not count them but have only gained a single response from a single councillor one time only. Outside of Dane valley I know of two councillors besides yourself that have deemed me worthy of a reply and they are seen largely as the rouges (such as David Green or Iris Johnson).

We can perhaps add you Cllr Mike Harrison to the tiny short-list of councillors that know how to communicate. This group are the minority though.

In Dane Valley prior to the last elections there were three councillors of both main parties. Of those councillors exactly none at all stood for re-election. Not only is the system burning up the hope of the people it's burning through the available political representatives too.

I started blogging because I could not get so much as a "screw you" from the council at any level and even after I posted photographical evidence of the problem all I managed to get was (1) a ride in an ambulance, (2) a half hearted police investigation that failed to do more than chat to the foreman (twice) and demand I sign off and (3) threatened with eviction due to some "breach" of my tenancy agreement that no one was willing to present the slightest shred of evidence for (as it was entirely fabricated by the building crew that handed me a swift concussion there was no evidence to present).

So as you can see: from the trenches there is nothing that suggests that all councillors (even the few that talk to me and don't think it beneath them) are not a guilty as the next. This is nothing personal, indeed I don't even know a single councillor socially (although I do sometimes sit on a bard or two with a few and they seem nice as individuals), but that's the problem. Until some councillors start making these massive shortcomings in both the system and the perceived attitude of the administration their (personal) problem and act like all life on this planet depends on the outcome no party will gain more than 2% of the estate votes nor the respect of the people at large.

In short Thanet needs a hero, it needs not just action but significant and positive change that is both bold and strong and aimed squarely and directly at improving the life of the average guy on the street. We need someone strong enough to take on the clubs and factions and say that anything short of "excellent" is not good enough. We need to make our constitution in whatever shape it is and hold it as HOLY above all else.

Yes we might need to write a better version but first we must treat it with the highest respect. Or at least some respect.

We need the braver to say that breach of the constitution and moral code by a councillor is something so rare and shocking that resignation would be the only honourable solution.

We need to confess our collective and institutionalised sins, admit that we have systematised the lowest of standards with our self seeking; ask for the forgiveness of the people of Thanet and then do better. Given the votes so far cast in the mini-poll I can assure you that the party that is is seen to rid us of this man will be assured at least 17 more votes in the next elections and probably a lot more.

To summarise quickly and to bring this to an end - it is not I nor the people that have tarred all councillors with the same brush but, without knowing it, the councillors themselves that have done this. The answer to this requires bravery - intra-party loyalty, deals, verbal treaties, friendships and rivalries will all be challenged and this could cost a councillor a lot "both on and off the playing field". With such bravery comes the reward of doing some long term good.

I urge every councillor to buck the party line if need be, to disregard the power plays and deals that might have gotten you "the choicest cuts" in the past and move unstoppably towards a real solution for Thanet. It will be hard, many will disapprove, many will oppose you, some will disown you and maybe some of you will feel the world is against you - but at the end over 100,000 people will benefit and remember.

Furl Newsvine Spurl.net reddit Tailrank del.icio.us BlinkList linkaGoGo Shadows Simpy digg kinja Magnolia Squidoo Technorati Yahoo My Web AskJeeves Google Windows Live Favorites

Have your say (there are ) · read more items categorised Thanet · Don't miss a thing: Subscribe Today · Help: what's a feed? · This site is operated on set principles of policy and disclosure read them here

Public Comments

Rick wrote:

Matt

When we lived in the Monmouth Constituency my MP was Roger Evans a tory barrister.

He could read and decide what actions he would take from reports (written by me) at the rate of about 19 pages per 5 minutes.

As he read he stuck those stick on note slips to the under side of each sheet and noted what he would do.

If I phoned him weeks later hw would remember without reference to notes every witness name and their relationship to the case.

His agent told me that the amount of constituency work he got through was awesome.

Huw Edwards his Labour predecessor, previously a lecturer in social policy, had taken half an hour and was still asking explanations about page one of the same report that Evans could assimilate in 5 minutes.

The tory agent told me about one incident when Roger was the new tory MP. A boundary dispute that had become hugely complex and involved gallons of paperwork. Evans scan reads, picks out all the salient legal issues and says "Site meeting with the parties"

Within five minutes of being at site and Roger setting out their cases it was mediated and the opposing factions shook hands and a decade old dispute was resolved.

But when Roger accepted a consultancy with a West Country Development Agency the South Wales Argus headlined "Traitor to Wales". And his response that the Severn Bridge is there to join not to divide ... fell on deaf ears.

No matter how great the hero, or how awesome his individuial ability, the little men will seek to pull him down rather than lift themselves up.

And Thanet is full of little men.

Just read the blogs:

"What with mention of BNP I won't use my name"

"I don't want to face a legal juggernaut"

Anonymous Biggles

Anonymous Eastcliff Richard champion of influence without consequence.

But whose site gets the most comments ?

The anonymous one. The coward's one.

Thanet gets what Thanet deserves and since it is home to the manufacture of unreliable backup generators which cut power to life support in hospitals and no Thanetian who could and should give evidence gives a toss, I hope it gets a whole sight worse. Because your guilty by association argument is applicable to the area as a whole and not just the council.
05/08/2008 20:09:58

Matt B wrote:

You say that the guilt by assosiation applies to us too. You are right in that if you look at a "them" whoever they might be the most commonly seen attributes are assumed to belong to all. So we Thanet people are generally lazy and vote badly if at all. We are mostly despondent about the state of things and feel that we can make no difference and so give up.

You cite an instance of an admirable man gifted with mental abilities that placed him above the norm. In your illustration (of which I know nothing beyond that which you have told me) this man is both talented and worthy of respect but I would stop short of calling him a hero although no doubt he was a hero to those he helped.

What happened when he left illustrates perfectly the core of the problem here in Thanet but not as you might think.

Clearly this man had done a great deal of good because that was his nature the people had therefore invested hope in this man. Hope is something that we have very little of here in Thanet. When he left hopes were dashed - what you call small-mindedness (and it could well ahve been that too) found expression and support in the feeling of loss that goes with a dashed hope.

There is a proverb that says "a hope deferred makes the heart sick". Likewise here in Thanet we have seen so many deferred hopes, so many hopes dashed and even so many promeses shown to be lies that no one has any hope left to build faith in anything with.

Faith, in case you are wondering, is the substance of things hoped for.
Without hope one can not have faith. Without faith why would anyone choose to act? Without action from those that are good those who are evil and abusive go unchallenged.

Hope, therefore, is the most vital element in regeneration, in prosperity and in building up.

So when people have no faith that justice will be done they will not testify. When we have no faith that voting will make any difference we boycott the vote and watch soaps on TV. When there is no faith in the system, the cynical and mocking voice is the voice of the people.

When there is no faith in any inherent justice in a system then people choose not to show their true face for fear of reprisals. Where faith is broken fear remains. I doubt you have failed to notice that around 90% of Thanet bloggers do not give their real name. This is a figure way way higher than anywhere else I know of.

What is needed now is a hero. The hero need not have great and impressive skills and abilities (although these things can help). The hero must have the one thing that is missing - a passion for Thanet shown not in words but deeds. In short Thanet requires the same sort of love that has always compelled men to give up their lives to protect those they care for. Anything less would be a half measure.
06/08/2008 11:17:00

Add Comment

Please note that while email addresses may be given via this form they are not shown to anyone but the editor. This change is retrospective and has hidden all email addresses so that people wishing anonymity may have it.

If you have a blog or other website of your own leaving the URL in this form will create a "do follow" link for Joined Up Blogging at the top of your comment.

Supporting Thanet traders

The following ebay listings are largely from Thanet based members (although items with a strong Thanet theme may also be included).

Get an advert on Thanet Star for a pound.
 

Thanet Star's Microblog

 Get Microblog by feed

Thanet's only microblog - tiny wee blog posts from Thanet.

Nagging TDC.

Don't forget to complain about parking costs: click here to so now

Getting talked about is good.

I've just noticed Thanet Star is being talked about again. But it's all good.

Local Journalism?

Why is it that thy don't get it. http://tinyurl.com/6hnp3y

New Blog in Thanet.

It's all about Margate. http://tinyurl.com/5aca8e

Twitter update

Alan Sugar due in Margate catch the tweet here

Thanet Star get's talked about

It seems I might have missed an email (whoops). Still some very nice things being said about Thanet Star on twitter!

Thanet Finder Blog Profiles

Trying out the Thanet Finder blog profile page system. Check it out

Thanet Star @Twitter

Twitter.com could be thought of as a giant global chat. You can keep up to date with Thanet Star at Twitter (free account recommend but not required) including updates from the microblog (here) and the headlines from the main blog. The Twitter feed will also include exclusive content not found else where.

Recent Comments

bertie biggles says Good luck with the break, Matt and come back when rested. Best wishes, old...

Rick says Thanet is apparently top of the country for the incidence of ectopic pregnancy. It...

Chris Wells says There are some of us who have been campaigning about thos growing problem since the...

Matt B says Rick, the plural of anecdote is not data. carma, I wonder if it makes us one...

carma says I heard about the leap second and I had started planning the most productive way to...

Rick says Re your interest in poverty Matt. As you know I have retired from Thanet site...

Matt B says I hope we will still see you around.

Matt B says Thanks for letting us know Karen.

Karen K says Vale Square are closed until 14 jan 2009

Rick says Happy New Year Matt. As you are aware I have retired from Thanet blogging. However...

Matt B says Thanks for the update, Angela. I wonder what the council is playing at some days. In...

Angela says The public consultation at Northdown House was agin an absolute shambles the same as...

The Thanet Star

↑ Grab this Headline Animator

Thanet Finder: Search Thanet

Thanet Finder is Thanet's search engine created by people like me and you.



The following links area provided as is. Thanet Star is not responsible for the content of third party sites.

Additional Points of Presence


Contact Matt

If you would like to chat with Thanet Star's Editor Matt B then a number of options are available to you. (You can also leave a message).

If you are a skype user you can chat live whenever he is online. The indicator below shows when Matt is on Skype.

My status

You can also get hold of him on Yahoo IM, MSN IM and GTalk if you know how. However, the screen name(s) he uses on these services are not public.

Connect with Matt on twitter as @thanetstar

Talk with matt on facebook

Matthew Brown's Facebook Profile

Connect on Live in Thanet