The Thanet Star

Blocking spam in the short term

My apologies to my regular and irregular commenters but I have had to activate an anti spam question while I write a more sophisticated way of filtering junk. While irritating it is less irritating than seeing six thousand links for the local blue pill. This anti spam question takes the form of a random and dead easy question that is added to the form.

It will remain until I have the time to write a sophisticated filter that can actually analyse the comment and figure out if it is spam. I could bore you with the technical and geek details (think "Bayesian methods" or the like) but the short story is that I have something in mind. Until then, sadly, you have to answer a stupid question to post a comment.

Sorry.


Furl Newsvine Spurl.net reddit Tailrank del.icio.us BlinkList linkaGoGo Shadows Simpy digg kinja Magnolia Squidoo Technorati Yahoo My Web AskJeeves Google Windows Live Favorites

Have your say (there are ) · read more items categorised Thanet · Don't miss a thing: Subscribe Today · Help: what's a feed? · This site is operated on set principles of policy and disclosure read them here

Public Comments

Michael Clild wrote:

Matt I hate to say this but the only way I have managed to deal with sinking under both email and blog spam is aol.com and blogger.com I have tried the geek approach and it failed with the emails, letting through spam and deleting my customers orders. The only difficulty o find with blogger is that I can’t post on it from my mobile pda and with aol that I cant access my email with it.
10/02/2008 10:52:28

Matt B wrote:

My email is a done deal, more or less, I use spam assasin server side and Thunderbird client side. Also I only have a few inboxes that I keep active for others and lots that I expire. This keeps my address out of the hands of spammers.

As for comment spam, I beat it at other sites by using captcha but I am aware that more subtle methods can work. I think the solution I have brewing will do the job nicely. Blogger.com is far to limited for me.

I can see why so many people give up though.
10/02/2008 14:16:02

Matt B wrote:

While we were saying that some kind soul sent me 20,000 spam comments. While around half of those came through before I noticed they did provide excellent training for the new Bayesian style AI system.

The trick is to defend the system with layers. Layer one is the user layer - this can have a question, image or some other humanity test on it. The next layer is the core where the data is inspected for quality. But a wrapper layer can be added that detects the bots before they start acting up.

So far I have two of the three in place and everything is holding up. When I am done even a whisper of spam will be rare. No one attacks my servers to any gain, ever.
10/02/2008 20:14:15

michael child wrote:

Matt the problem with email is that if you are in business you have to retain the same email address for years and publish it on the web as much as possible. I used to use my domain email and generate @michaelsbooksbop.com addresses in the end I was having to look at 100s of spam emails a day.

I also notice that you don’t come up on Thanet blog list, recent feeds but am not sure if this is something to do with your settings or endemic to your hosting.

I am considering ways of making the michaelsbookshop.com site more interactive and something interactive in the shop window maybe based on some sort of ipod technology or possibly some sort of capacitive activated touch screen that I could stick on the inside of the glass.

Can you imagine the problems with some sort of news blog that people could operate from the street? Frankly I think we are going down the road where technology and promotional equipment that isn’t interactive won’t even get noticed.

But certainly something similar to a blog that can be operated free from the street by anyone is a road I very much want to go down, any ideas greatly appreciated.
11/02/2008 10:51:38

Matt B wrote:

Of the top of my head I can think of a few products that might be something like what you are looking at. The total investment is going to be coming up on four figures and I would not be at all surprised if it went past that mark before the end. I'll try to email you some thoughts on the subject in the next few days.
11/02/2008 14:39:09

Michael Child wrote:

Matt I am thinking in terms of a lot less money one option could be http://www.thinkgeek.com/co... another controlling functions in a similar way to the way the playstation eye toy works or perhaps something like the old Sinclair touch sensitive keyboard.
12/02/2008 12:55:29

Matt B wrote:

I'm currently looking into some newer technology but so far I have no idea of price. In theory the ideal solution would be sufficiently inexpensive to start a trend.
07/03/2008 13:46:58

Add Comment

Please note that while email addresses may be given via this form they are not shown to anyone but the editor. This change is retrospective and has hidden all email addresses so that people wishing anonymity may have it.

If you have a blog or other website of your own leaving the URL in this form will create a "do follow" link for Joined Up Blogging at the top of your comment.

Supporting Thanet traders

The following ebay listings are largely from Thanet based members (although items with a strong Thanet theme may also be included).

Get an advert on Thanet Star for a pound.
 

Thanet Star's Microblog

Thanet's only microblog - tiny snippets of information updated often.

Thanet Finder Blog Profiles

Trying out the Thanet Finder blog profile page system. Check it out

Thanet Star @Twitter

Twitter.com could be thought of as a giant global chat. You can keep up to date with Thanet Star at Twitter (free account recommend but not required) including updates from the microblog (here) and the headlines from the main blog. The Twitter feed will also include exclusive content not found else where.

Profiteering with China Gateway

Profiteering over the China Gateway have started already. Someone aims to make a quick buck with a well timed domain name - read more.

Travel Information

In answer to questions raised in Buses - TDC's Answer to Traffic Problems (apparently) a visiting reader, Dave, suggested the travel site travelinesoutheast.org.uk and he was right on the money - they are very good.

Empty Rates in Thanet

Thanet Businesses are currently being defended by Thanet's MPs it seems. read more

Thanet Earth delayed

Thanet Earth has been delayed read more

Poetry and Art Blog

A New blogger joins the ranks! Say hallo to Shelley Skinner.

Scenic Railway Saved?

A £30,000 award will go towards plans to restore the Scenic Railway destroyed by the fire back in April. read more

Recent Comments

Mike says Do we have a democratic voice? You're having a laugh right? TDC couldn't...

Matt B says Let's hope so if only for the publicity (I'm not sure if I would actually show up...

Lily says Tracy is good friends with Jane at the Walpole Bay Hotel,so I am sure she will do...

Matt B says I believe that the exhibit has ended now but I'm sure these items will be seen again...

dreamyacht says I would love to have the opportunity to visit this exhibit... I believe that just...

Matt B says No adverts please.

Matt B says Didn't she say something about Margate being worthless or something equally pleasant...

andrew says Re Wells, Doesn't Margate's Tracy as a local, have the necessary artistic skills and...

Matt B says If the "other side" didn't represent then yes it might be squewed. Maybe...

Dave C says I can't see anything being achieved other than a very one sided debate.

Matt B says You are quite welcome. Welcome to the world of Thanet Blogs.

Shelley Skinner says Thanks Matt, I have only just realised that you have posted this. Duh! I will add a...

The Thanet Star

↑ Grab this Headline Animator

Thanet Finder: Search Thanet

Thanet Finder is Thanet's search engine created by people like me and you.



The following links area provided as is. Thanet Star is not responsible for the content of third party sites.

Additional Points of Presence


Contact Matt

If you would like to chat live with Thanet Star's Editor Matt B then a number of options are available to you. (You can also leave a message).

If you are a skype user you can chat live whenever he is online.

My status

You can also get hold of him on Yahoo IM, MSN IM and GTalk if you know how.